Week 3 Reading Thoughts


  • It's interesting how countries with a history of colonialism have historically been more welcoming to refugees, though clearly this is not always the case as time progresses.  Are there other countries that have been historically welcoming to refugees which were not colonial powers (US, England) or have colonial history (US, Australia, Canada)
  • The realities of discriminatory immigration policy seem so obvious; people are going to migrate either way and either you offer them a path to citizenship or you marginalize them and force them to isolate themselves from the rest of the country's society, to the determent of everyone.  Even from a purely fiscal view, you clearly end up with illegal immigrants working for cash, not income paying taxes, and a much higher risk for them to be exploited for their labor either through wages under the minimum, or unsafe conditions.  As popular as limiting immigration can be in some places, it's sad that politicians choose these policies over ones that would, in the long run, likely benefit everyone.
  • I had no idea about the burst of racist violence directly after the fall of the Berlin Wall.  The more I read the more I realize I don't actually know much about this period in Europe's history.  Definitely something I want to read more about, both in general and in relation to our class.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Reading Reflection 7/5

FIGURE OF THE MIGRANT THOUGHTS It's always interesting to me how many assumptions we have that we don't openly think about or recognize. The assumption or stereotype of migrant as a 'failed citizen' is one that I think many of us subconsciously have, even if we do not believe that they have failed because of their own choices. In many cases, we view them as being from a failed state, and this judgment, too, is one that should be openly addressed and critiqued. The chapter mentions that 'the most 'dispossessed refugees have created some of the most interesting non-state social organizations'. I am recording this partially as a reminder to look for some of these later. Often when people think of immigrant organizations it is criminal organizations that come to mind. A few years ago I read an interesting piece about the idea that organized crime is an almost necessary step for any immigrant community in a “1 st world” coun
Read more

Journal Entry IV

Did you post witnesses? he said. To report to you on the continuing existence of those places once you’d quit them? That’s crazy. Is it? Where is yesterday? -Cormac McCarthy,  Blood Meridian Memory is something, as Julie pointed out in feedback this week, that shows up in most of my reflections and longer journal entries.  This one isn't going to be any different. I'm sitting in the Jetpack Ecolodge in Grunwald, just outside of Berlin.  It is Monday morning.  I have just said goodbye to Zosia as she headed out to get her taxi to the airport and, though Sophie will be here another day, I feel pretty alone in a way that is both sad and exciting, and she too will leave tomorrow and then I really will be the last one in Berlin. It makes a strange sense:  I was the first one of the group in the city, followed by Sophie half a day later, so I should be the last one out.  To truly complete the palindrome I should have stayed in Lichtenstein again but I wanted to se
Read more

Journal Entry II

I still feel that I between the flooding and the Hamburg trip, I haven't had time to fully process everything we saw at Sachenhausen.  The last 4 days have been unrelenting each in their own different ways.  That being said, there are many impressions I got while there that I'm sure will form more fully even as I write this.  For that reason, I'm mostly I'm going to talk about the Sachenhausen part of the week. The first, strongest thing that I felt there was the sense of hallowedness that I had on some level expected.  I have dozens of photos from other places we've been.  I have three from that place.  I know others have felt the same, and the few pictures I did take almost felt wrong when I was taking them, and I found that I had to explain to myself that it will be important to show people what it was like when I get home, and that's why it was okay to take a small amount of photos.  It's an entirely different kind of documentation, even though we w
Read more